🔗 Share this article

Supporters for a private school system established to teach Hawaiian descendants describe a fresh court case targeting the acceptance policies as a blatant attempt to disregard the intentions of a monarch who donated her fortune to secure a improved prospects for her community almost 140 years ago.

The Legacy of Princess Bernice Pauahi Bishop

The Kamehameha schools were created through the testament of the royal descendant, the descendant of the founding monarch and the last royal descendant in the dynasty. Upon her passing in 1884, the princess’s estate contained roughly 9% of the Hawaiian islands' overall land.

Her will set up the learning institutions using those holdings to finance them. Now, the system encompasses three campuses for elementary through high school and 30 early learning centers that focus on learning centered on native culture. The centers instruct approximately 5,400 pupils throughout all educational levels and maintain an trust fund of about $15 bn, a sum exceeding all but approximately ten of the nation's top higher education institutions. The institutions take not a single dollar from the U.S. treasury.

Selective Enrollment and Economic Assistance

Entrance is very rigorous at every level, with only about a fifth of students being accepted at the upper school. The institutions additionally support approximately 92% of the price of educating their learners, with virtually 80% of the student body furthermore receiving different types of economic assistance based on need.

Historical Context and Cultural Importance

Jon Osorio, the dean of the Hawaiʻinuiākea School of Hawaiian Knowledge at the UH, explained the Kamehameha schools were founded at a period when the Native Hawaiian population was still on the downward trend. In the 1880s, roughly 50,000 indigenous people were believed to dwell on the islands, down from a maximum of from 300,000 to 500,000 inhabitants at the period of initial encounter with Westerners.

The native government was truly in a unstable situation, especially because the United States was growing increasingly focused in securing a permanent base at Pearl Harbor.

The dean noted throughout the 20th century, “nearly all native practices was being sidelined or even eradicated, or very actively suppressed”.

“In that period of time, the learning centers was really the only thing that we had,” the academic, a former student of the institutions, commented. “The establishment that we had, that was just for us, and had the potential at the very least of keeping us abreast of the rest of the population.”

The Lawsuit

Today, the vast majority of those admitted at the institutions have Hawaiian descent. But the fresh legal action, lodged in district court in the city, says that is unjust.

The case was filed by a group known as the plaintiff organization, a conservative group located in the state that has for decades waged a legal battle against preferential treatment and race-based admissions practices. The group challenged the Ivy League university in 2014 and finally achieved a historic judicial verdict in 2023 that saw the conservative judges end ethnicity-based enrollment in colleges and universities nationwide.

An online platform established recently as a forerunner to the Kamehameha schools suit states that while it is a “great school system”, the centers' “acceptance guidelines expressly prefers learners with indigenous heritage rather than applicants of other backgrounds”.

“Indeed, that priority is so strong that it is virtually not possible for a applicant of other ethnicity to be accepted to Kamehameha,” Students for Fair Admission claims. “We believe that focus on ancestry, instead of merit or need, is neither fair nor legal, and we are pledged to terminating Kamehameha’s improper acceptance criteria via judicial process.”

Political Efforts

The effort is headed by a conservative activist, who has led groups that have filed over twelve lawsuits questioning the application of ancestry in education, industry and in various organizations.

Blum declined to comment to press questions. He stated to another outlet that while the association backed the Kamehameha schools’ mission, their services should be accessible to every resident, “not only those with a specific genetic background”.

Educational Implications

Eujin Park, an assistant professor at the teaching college at Stanford, explained the court case challenging the educational institutions was a notable instance of how the fight to undo anti-discrimination policies and guidelines to promote equitable chances in educational institutions had transitioned from the arena of post-secondary learning to elementary and high schools.

The professor said activist entities had challenged Harvard “quite deliberately” a decade ago.

I think the challenge aims at the Kamehameha schools because they are a exceptionally positioned school… similar to the way they chose the college with clear intent.

The scholar explained while race-conscious policies had its detractors as a somewhat restricted instrument to increase learning access and entry, “it was an crucial resource in the repertoire”.

“It was a component of this broader spectrum of policies accessible to educational institutions to increase admission and to establish a fairer academic structure,” she stated. “To lose that instrument, it’s {incredibly harmful